best places to eat in montauk

best places to eat in montauk

We know how important food is for your body, and for your mood. And so we’ve decided to give you a list of the best restaurants on Montauk that offer healthy and delicious meals, whether you’re on vacation or are just looking for a good place to eat at the end of a long day. Whether it’s your first time in Montauk or you’re a frequent visitor, it’s always nice to know what restaurants are best. With so many options available, it’s hard to determine which ones truly stand out. However, there are actually quite a few outstanding establishments on the East End that are more than worth your while.

If you’re looking for the best places to eat in Montauk, look no further! We’ve got you covered with a list of our favorite establishments.

Montauk is a great place to eat out because it offers a wide range of options. You can walk into any kind of restaurant: from fast food joints to fine dining spots.

But we’re not here to talk about all that—we’re here to tell you what we think are the best places to eat in Montauk. So without further ado, here’s our list of favorites:

1) The Beach House Restaurant & Bar – If you want to treat yourself and enjoy an incredible meal with views that will take your breath away, head over here. This place has been around since 1919 and is still going strong today! It’s also one of the most popular spots in town so reservations are recommended if you want to avoid waiting outside for hours on end before being seated inside (you won’t have any problem getting one during off-season though). They serve up some mouthwatering seafood dishes and other classics like steak or pasta but don’t forget about dessert—they have pies too!

Montauk is a great place to visit for anyone who loves the ocean and its many offerings. Whether you’re looking for a quiet place to unwind and relax, or the excitement of dining in a bustling restaurant, Montauk has something for everyone.

If you’re looking for a quiet place to get away from it all, there are several restaurants in Montauk that can provide just that. One of the most popular spots is The Lighthouse Restaurant & Bar, which offers both indoor and outdoor seating. You’ll be treated to views of Long Island Sound as you enjoy some of their delicious seafood dishes.

If you prefer a more lively atmosphere, then head over to The Blue Parrot Restaurant & Bar, which features live music on Saturday nights. This restaurant has been around since 1957, making it one of the oldest in town. It’s known for serving up some delicious seafood dishes along with other favorites such as burgers and sandwiches too!

Another great spot for seafood lovers is The Surf Lodge Restaurant & Bar where you’ll find plenty of options like lobster rolls or shrimp tacos on their brunch menu alone! They also offer other varieties including grilled salmon or tuna steak if those aren’t exactly your thing either though!

top eats in montauk

1. Sel Rrose

Its name was drawn from the female alter-ego of renowned French painter Marcel Duchamp, paying tribute to modern art in the early 1900s.

Why This Restaurant Is a Must Eat

No list of the top Montauk restaurants would be complete without this artsy and vibrant place.

Its interiors evoke a cozy vibe while the outdoors provide a natural and calming atmosphere overlooking the waters.

It’s the most Instagram-worthy among the best restaurants downtown.

Of course, the sumptuous seafood and cocktails in this casual place are beyond comparison.

What to Eat

Order the special Le Sel Rrose Plateau to know what makes the oysters in this place outstanding.

Aside from a dozen oysters, it also includes six shrimp and six clams that will give you a satisfying experience.

Pair it up with The Fountain, one of the highly sought-after craft cocktails on the bar, for a complete course.

It’s a mix of gin, lemon, and grapefruit that introduces you to a unique flavor you’ll love.

2. Ditch Witch

Since 1994, Ditch Witch has been serving tasty food and drinks at Ditch Plains Beach.

It was featured in the New York Times and other major news outlets due to its unique setup and nice offerings.

Why This Restaurant Is a Must Eat

This food truck became one of the most popular dining hubs for beachgoers over the past two decades.

It provides fulfilling breakfast meals to energize you before your early morning surf.

If you need healthy food options, have no worries since the Ditch Witch also has vegan and gluten-free items on the menu.

What to Eat

Have a chia bowl mixed with blueberries, coconut, granola, and honey that’s perfect for vegans.

Hot and iced drinks are available here as well.

Take the Missy’s Mixed Plate if you prefer a heavier meal that comes with white rice and other special options.

Never skip the Ditch Witch wraps with cheese, veggies, and chicken, too.

You’ll need this for a quick bite especially if you’re taking a road trip outside Montauk.

3. TT’s Montauk

TT’s Montauk stands as another hip and trendy bungalow-type restaurant near the lake.

It’s located steps away from the Block Island Ferry Service going to Rhode Island.

Why This Restaurant Is a Must Eat

Do you want to eat at one of the coolest fast-food restaurants in Montauk?

You’ve just found the one you’re looking for.

TT’s Montauk features simple yet charming designs with pops of pink all around.

It’s a great food destination especially for kids who love light snacks.

Plus, this place is also one of the good restaurants in Montauk serving Texas-Mexican food.

What to Eat

Try their very own hot chicken sandwich that comes with blue cheese and fries on the side.

4. Westlake Fish House

It was originally established in 2014.

Why This Restaurant Is a Must Eat

There’s no doubt Westlake Fish House serves the best food in Montauk.

Want to know why?

It’s because they use fresh seafood directly coming from Westlake Marina in front of the restaurant.

You might even see the staff prepping the fresh catch just before sending it to the kitchen.

In addition, this casual American dining place boasts a lovely outdoor setup by the waters.

Indoor seating and a bar area are also available as alternative options.

What to Eat

Westlake Fish House rose to popularity because of its delectable sushi offerings so you should try it out.

Consider ordering their specialty roll named Westlake to discover the superb flavor of spicy tuna, avocado, and shiso.

It also has a fluke and seabass.

Its clam chowder and grilled hamburger have also earned compliments from guests so you should try them out.

unique restaurants in montauk

The Tavern at The Chequit

Part of this season’s Shelter Island renaissance, the Chequit hotel has three restaurants from North Fork chef Noah Schwartz, and this New American is farm-to-table focused. Schwartz’s signature smash burger is on the menu, along with steaks, homemade pastas, a pulled-duck barbecue, and a raw bar. In addition to the dining room with a large center bar and an antique billiard table, there is a wrap-around porch.

Navy Beach, Montauk

There are only a few places where you can actually dine on the sand out east, and this scenic Montauk spot with spectacular sunsets is one of them. Tuna crudo with papaya, pickled serrano, and toasted sesame is a great local starter, and soy-glazed halibut with sushi rice and red curry coconut; or dry-aged ribeye with crispy smashed potatoes are solid entree choices.


This funky Montauk bar made history when the Rolling Stones regularly played pool and drank there in the ‘70s, and while it still attracts a big nightlife crowd, the outdoor space has morphed into a lovely dining area where you can opt for a range of classics, from fish ’n’chips to seafood paella or a NY strip steak.

Clam Bar at Napeague

Sit outside in shorts and flip-flops at this 40-year-old roadside spot on the Napeague stretch and indulge in various forms of lobster, from rolls to giant steamed crustaceans.  While there you might want to pick up some fun merchandise, including a baby bib and a vintage sweatshirt.

Wölffer Kitchen Amagansett

Located within picturesque Amagansett Square, the restaurant owned and operated by Wolffer Vineyard attracts an interesting crowd and serves an array of wine by the glass – largely from its Wolffer, not surprisingly. The approachable menu includes an extremely crisp chopped Greek salad; and seared tuna with black forbidden rice.

Leave a Comment